Vitalik Buterin wrote that supporting DAOs with transferable governance tokens is contradictory and enables the power-hungry.
The governance discussion intensifies as decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs)
become more popular in the blockchain space. The dilemma between giving
power to a specific few and the freedom to voluntarily delegate
decision power was highlighted in a Twitter thread created by Ethereum
founder Vitalik Buterin.
In a tweet, Buterin brought up an
old adage pointing out that power-hungry individuals are not suitable
to lead. The Ethereum founder highlighted that the saying can be applied
to DAOs and argued that transferable governance tokens in DAOs
contradict the whole point of DAOs. Buterin noted that if governance can
be transferred, it enables those who are after power.
While the Ethereum founder presents a valid point, some reacted with contrasting opinions. In a reply, Twitter user Muki pointed out that
it’s inevitable to delegate decision power. According to the community
member, expecting everyone to participate is impossible, and a voluntary
delegation of decision power is better than making uninformed decisions
or not participating at all.
Contributing to the discussion, Twitter user Willyogo wrote
that holding transferable governance tokens does not equate to wanting
to rule people. However, the community member also said that there’s
definitely room for improvement for DAOs in terms of voting mechanics.
Twitter user Vagobond also chimed in,
saying that having fully recallable delegates is a way to move forward.
In this idea, the delegates who were picked could instantly lose their
authority the moment they stop representing those who delegated votes to
them.
While others focused on governance mechanics, some pointed
to the use of blockchain-based technologies like picking important
positions in a DAO using verifiable randomness. Another community member suggested randomly selecting token holders and rotating when the selected holder does not show on-chain activity.
Related: Lido DAO: Ethereum’s biggest Merge staker soars 400% in July — but technicals flash warning
In the recent Ethereum Community Conference held in Paris, Web3 adviser Hilary Kivitz discussed DAOs and how they can fight off hostile takeovers. According to Kivitz, there are solutions such as adding poison pills into smart contracts to dilute the votes of exploiters.
Meanwhile, in a recent interview with Cointelegraph, Alex Tapscott mentioned that DAO developments are something to look out for
during the bear market. Tapscott highlighted that DAOs have the
potential to replace traditional organizations in organizing resources.
source link : https://cointelegraph.com/news/eth-founder-speaks-against-transferable-governance-community-responds
